Valley's FA Cup meetings against Stourbridge are probably best remembered as Rugby came out on top after replays in 1984 & 1985 to earn a place in the first round proper.

Since slipping out of the Southern League in 1999, Stourbridge have not made many trips to Butlin Road, with only an FA Cup tie in 2000 and a Southern League Cup fourth round tie in 06/07.

However, Stourbridge gained a place in the BGB Premier Division for the 08/09 season with promotion through the play-offs in the Midland Division.

Date		Comp			Att	Scorers	Rep	Pht
29 Nov 11	H	SLC 2		4-3	131	Lake-Gaskin, Keen 2, Preston
17 Apr 10	A	SLPD		0-6	206	-
28 Nov 09	H	SLPD		1-2	208	Staff
27 Jan 09	A	SLPD		1-1	173	Stone
7 Oct 08	H	SLPD		4-0	169	Gordon, Kolodynski 2, Purton
30 Jan 07	H	SLC 4		2-1	133	Taylor, Blenkinsopp
5 Sept 00	H	FACqpR		2-2*	199	O'Brien, Beard
2 Sept 00	A	FACqp		0-0	-	-
6 Mar 99	A	SLMD		1-0	-	John
22 Aug 98	H	SLMD		0-2	265	-
7 Apr 98	A	SLMD		0-4	-	-
6 Dec 97	H	SLMD		0-1	263	-
26 Apr 97	A	SLMD		2-1	-	Owen 2
30 Nov 96	H	SLMD		2-1	244	Tonge, Marsh
29 Jan 94	A	SLMD		1-3	-	Warner
30 Oct 93	H	SLMD		2-0	524	Alsop, Warner
16 Mar 93	A	BSC SF		4-2	-	Warner 2, OG, Hardwick
7 Feb 87	H	SLMD		2-0	491	Martin, Ross
27 Dec 86	A	SLMD		1-3	-	P Geddes
31 Mar 86	A	SLMD		1-0	-	Norris
15 Mar 86	H	SLMD		0-0	307	-
30 Oct 85	H	FACq4R		3-1	1383	Norris 2, OG
28 Oct 85	A	FACq4		1-1	-	Gorman (p)
20 Mar 85	H	SLMD		2-2	380	Ingram, Gorman (p)
30 Oct 84	H	FACq4R		2-0	1676	Ingram, Crawley
27 Oct 84	A	FACq4		1-1	-	Crawley
1 Sept 84	A	SLMD		1-2	-	Webb

* Stourbridge win on penalties after extra time